The Allman Brothers Band
Your Mount Rushmore...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Your Mount Rushmore of Drummers

78 Posts
25 Users
4 Reactions
5,576 Views
oldcoot
(@oldcoot)
Posts: 4389
Famed Member
Topic starter
 

With the passing of Charlie Watts got to thinking of drummers who appealed to my own personal tastes. 

My personal "Mount Rushmore" would be Charlie, Billy Cobham, Neil Peart and Keith Moon.

Yours?


"Is that a real poncho or is that a Sears poncho?"

 
Posted : August 24, 2021 11:08 pm
matt05
(@matt05)
Posts: 1017
Noble Member
 

ginger baker, keith moon, carl palmer and cozy powell


 
Posted : August 24, 2021 11:41 pm
Stephen
(@stephen)
Posts: 3875
Famed Member
 

Bonzo, Keith Moon, Carl Palmer, equally similar in length of career/brilliance

some of my faves had short careers, like Ginger, MMitchell, Buddy Miles, Corky Laing - ie, knew little of their overall stuff

 

 

But yes, my Mt Rushmore would have tobe Charlie, Ringo, Butch & Jaimoe 

All those great Stones records - little tops their late 60s-early 70s output - Salt of the Earth was mentioned b4, how brilliant is Charlie in That one - great great musician

 


 
Posted : August 25, 2021 1:11 am
porkchopbob
(@porkchopbob)
Posts: 4634
Illustrious Member
 

Levon Helm

Bernard Purdie

Clyde Stubblefield

Butch & Jaimoe (they count as one)

Honorable mention: Al Jackson Jr


PorkchopBob Studio

 
Posted : August 25, 2021 9:09 am
stormyrider
(@stormyrider)
Posts: 1581
Noble Member
 

Elvin Jones

Art Blakey

Max Roach

Ringo

John Bonham


 
Posted : August 25, 2021 9:48 am
meandean
(@meandean)
Posts: 127
Estimable Member
 

Richie Hayward 

Zigaboo Modeliste

John Bonham 

Stanton Moore

Steve Jordan


 
Posted : August 25, 2021 10:46 am
robertdee
(@robertdee)
Posts: 6025
Illustrious Member
 

 

Butch and Jaimoe

John Bonham

Steve Gadd 

Neil Peart 

( When reading interviews with Neil Peart and Phil Collins both after having great things to say about other drummers, said Buddy Rich is probably the greatest drummer we've had. So I'm including Buddy though he was such an egotistical jack a**)

Buddy Rich 

 


 

 


This post was modified 4 years ago by robertdee
 
Posted : August 25, 2021 11:32 am
owencarol
(@owencarol)
Posts: 201
Estimable Member
 

Buddy Rich
Ginger Baker
Butch
Art Blakey

In no particular order.

 


 
Posted : August 25, 2021 12:44 pm
steadyhorse
(@steadyhorse)
Posts: 257
Reputable Member
 

Ian Paice

Bill Ward

John Bonham 

Keith Moon

 


 
Posted : August 25, 2021 1:41 pm
Bill_Graham
(@bill_graham)
Posts: 2795
Famed Member
 

Butch Trucks/ Jaimoe

Matt Abt's

John Bonham

Billy Cobham


 
Posted : August 25, 2021 2:50 pm
Lee
 Lee
(@lee)
Posts: 9538
Illustrious Member
 

Stanton Moore is a good one. I've seen him sit in with the ABB a few times and I love Galactic. 

Matt Abts is great.

One I haven't seen mentioned is John Bonham's son Jason. 

Marc Quinones is great. I think he kinda flew under the radar playing with Butch & Jaimoe.

 

 


Everything in Moderation. Including Moderation.

 
Posted : August 25, 2021 3:37 pm
robertdee
(@robertdee)
Posts: 6025
Illustrious Member
 

@lee Yeah when you have to choose four or five great drummers or another instrument, as soon as you have your list, you suddenly think of or someone points out other musicians who are great too:) 

Maybe that is why Rolling Stone had a list of 100 guitar players...and even with that many there were a couple I thought should have been on it that didn't make it. 

Buddy Rich, who certainly felt he was the best drummer or one of the best, said Chick Webb was the daddy of them all. Webb died in 1939 at 36 years of age and played in the house band at the Savoy Club in 1930's Harlem, New York City. I have yet to find any footage of Chick Webb. 

 

He is fast and his jazz band rocks!! But in the 1930's and 40's those uptown bands in Manhattan were always a little hotter and a bit more swing than the midtown and downtown bands! 


This post was modified 4 years ago by robertdee
 
Posted : August 25, 2021 5:21 pm
Buckeye
(@buckeye)
Posts: 139
Estimable Member
 

It's hard for me to 'hear' most drummers since I usually am primarily listening to the guitars/vocals in rock music.  Ginger Baker and Bonzo are two really grab my attention.  They cut through and stand out.


 
Posted : August 27, 2021 8:47 am
Rusty
(@rusty)
Posts: 3264
Famed Member
 

Krupa, Rich and a bunch of jazz guys nobody ever heard of!

For the "rock" guys, Carl Palmer, Ginger Baker, Stewart Copeland and (of course) Butch and Jaimoe.  Also, Chris Fryar (Zack Brown/Oteil and the Peacemakers).


 
Posted : August 27, 2021 10:13 am
robertdee
(@robertdee)
Posts: 6025
Illustrious Member
 

I've heard Jaimoe brag about Max Roach, Buddy Rich and Butch Trucks. Indeed Jaimoe said some of the coolest stuff he has done on the drums was in response to something Butch Trucks played. 

Can you hear some Jaimoe here and there? 


This post was modified 4 years ago by robertdee
 
Posted : August 27, 2021 5:59 pm
robertdee
(@robertdee)
Posts: 6025
Illustrious Member
 

When I saw Frank Sinatra with Count Basie in Manhattan in 1968, Sonny Payne was the drummer. Sonny is also on Frank and Basie's Live At The Sands 1966 which was a big seller. 


 
Posted : August 27, 2021 6:09 pm
Rusty reacted
robertdee
(@robertdee)
Posts: 6025
Illustrious Member
 

Pretty Purdie is another of my favorites.

 

And I was reading one of my old Drummer World magazines and in one from 1970 as to the fastest drummer playing Buddy Rich said that would be Buddy Rich!

 


This post was modified 4 years ago by robertdee
 
Posted : August 27, 2021 6:12 pm
Rusty reacted
aiq
 aiq
(@aiq)
Posts: 443
Honorable Member
 

Elvin Jones

Tony Williams

Dave Weckl

Jaimoe/Trucks

 

Will be different tomorrow.


 
Posted : August 30, 2021 12:34 pm
Rusty reacted
Rusty
(@rusty)
Posts: 3264
Famed Member
 

@aiq When places like my bank give those questions designed to help retrieve your account information, I can never use the "favorite singer/band" question because I know the answer will be different in a matter of days or even hours!

Back to topic:  there's also a TERRY Williams (Rockpile, Dave Edmunds, Dire Straits etc) who's a darn good drummer.


 
Posted : August 30, 2021 2:08 pm
stormyrider
(@stormyrider)
Posts: 1581
Noble Member
 
Posted by: @aiq

Elvin Jones

Tony Williams

Dave Weckl

Jaimoe/Trucks

 

Will be different tomorrow.

Weckl is amazing - I almost put him on my list but went for "pioneers"

A great educator, too


 
Posted : August 30, 2021 5:16 pm
jszfunk
(@jszfunk)
Posts: 4642
Illustrious Member
 


Everyone has a plan, till you get punched in the face,

 
Posted : August 31, 2021 7:52 am
Rusty
(@rusty)
Posts: 3264
Famed Member
 

Chevy Chase was actually a pretty good musician.  Drums?  How about Chevy as the drum?


 
Posted : August 31, 2021 9:28 am
robertdee
(@robertdee)
Posts: 6025
Illustrious Member
 

@jszfunk  Here is Animal in a drum battle with....according to Buddy Rich...the greatest and fastest drummer in the ENTIRE HISTORY OF MUSIC....BUDDY RICH HIMSELF!!!!

 

 

 


 
Posted : August 31, 2021 11:54 am
robertdee
(@robertdee)
Posts: 6025
Illustrious Member
 

 

Go over to the 6:00 minute mark and see the FASTEST DRUMMER ON EARTH before 1987. Anyone this fast now?

This leaves Steve Gadd, Neil Peart, Ginger Baker and Butch Trucks way back there in the dust. 

Looks as if you're gonna need to click on YouTube at the bottom of the gray box. 

 


This post was modified 4 years ago 2 times by robertdee
 
Posted : September 13, 2021 12:49 pm
robertdee
(@robertdee)
Posts: 6025
Illustrious Member
 

@rusty I imagine Jaimoe could be in this band. Top notch, top shelf jazz players. 

 

I watched this video carefully last night and if you are a drummer or like drumming, Buddy puts on a drum clinic here. Absolutely outstanding drum technique and timing. 

Neil Peart and Phil Collins said Buddy is probably the best we've ever had.  But he was a jazz and big band freak going back to the late 1930's and was apparently an egotistical hard nose in real life. Died in 1987. 

I'm big fans of a number of great drummers but Buddy as best I can tell was the best. 


This post was modified 4 years ago by robertdee
 
Posted : September 26, 2021 7:35 pm
Rusty reacted
linus
(@linus)
Posts: 90
Estimable Member
 

Butch/Jaimoe

Roger Hawkins

Benny Benjamin

Al. Jackson


 
Posted : September 29, 2021 4:25 pm
robertdee
(@robertdee)
Posts: 6025
Illustrious Member
 

@linus Those are all good drummers. Very good as a matter of fact. The Butch/Jaimoe combination was my favorite. 

Apparently Buddy Rich was the granddaddy of them all. Technically I agree with Neil Peart and Phil Collins that Buddy was the best we've had. 

But Buddy himself mentions Chick Webb as the one everyone in the late 1930's and 40's tried to emulate. Chick Webb played in Harlem and died young. 

Sonny Payne who was with Count Basie is another favorite. 

But Buddy Rich is the best I ever saw or watched on TV and YouTube. So it wasn't surprising when I saw Phil Collins say Buddy is the best drummer we've had so far. 


 
Posted : September 29, 2021 6:44 pm
linus
(@linus)
Posts: 90
Estimable Member
 

I admire flashy drummers, but I love guys who create a perfect pocket.  Benny Benjamin could have just as easily been Uriel Jones, Pistol Allen or Al Jackson.  As a bass player, those are my kind of guys.


 
Posted : September 29, 2021 6:53 pm
robertdee
(@robertdee)
Posts: 6025
Illustrious Member
 

Happy Birthday to Buddy Rich 🎉 born on this day in 1917. 

Buddy is often regarded by many including Neil Peart, Phil Collins and Buddy Rich as the greatest drummer we've had so far. I think he was. 


This post was modified 4 years ago by robertdee
 
Posted : September 30, 2021 9:58 am
robertdee
(@robertdee)
Posts: 6025
Illustrious Member
 

Read earlier that Phil Collins met Buddy Rich in the 1980's and Buddy had seen Genesis on TV and liked Phil. Phil ask Buddy for advice and Buddy said to get rid of the two bass drums and only use one and focus more on your high-hat and get looser on the ride cymbal. 

Buddy said the two bass drummers are BOOM, BOOM, BOOM, BOOM...and it's noise and not music. Getting real good on a high-hat adds so much to getting in there and playing some real music. 

Buddy said he has played with the greatest musicians in the world and when you're on that level you have to be tight, precise and in the groove at all times. And you can do it with 4 or 5 drums, high-hat, ride cymbal and a couple of crash cymbals. Don't need a lot of drums especially more than one bass drum. 


This post was modified 4 years ago 2 times by robertdee
 
Posted : September 30, 2021 4:27 pm
Page 1 / 3
Share: